Mu觀點
Mu觀點以部落格形式呈現Mu委員會成員及工作人員的觀點和個人文章。這些文章並不代表Mu的集體政策或立場,Mu的政策和立場在我們的原則頁面,以及本網站的其他頁面。
我們的主要作者:Brian Ribbon、Jim Burton、Percy Shelley、Tommaso Battista。
Brian Ribbon
Percy Shelley

「支持改革」是一套主張應透過審慎的法律改革,為 MAP 們及青少年提供更多權利與保障的框架。此框架反映了 Mu 兩位編輯的立場,但未必獲得 Mu 所有成員的認同。
支持改革的活動人士主張,MAP 與年輕人的公民自由無需以犧牲未成年人的安全為代價。我們支持採取理性且合乎邏輯的方針,避免在未造成實際傷害的情況下將人送進監獄,同時有效預防對兒童的實際虐待。政策不應僅基於厭惡感或主觀道德觀來禁止某些行為,也不應盲目假設哪些措施能有效預防傷害,這一點在監管「未成年人禁忌影像」(PIM)的政策上尤為明顯。本文延續我們先前提出的 AMSC(成人-未成年人性接觸)改革提案(連結),該提案旨在平衡未成年人的保護與自主權,同時也呼應我們關於「軟性」社會改革的文章。我們將探討PIM政策,並說明我們對法律改革的理念。
本文將使用的術語
在 Mu,我們使用縮寫「PIM」(未成年人禁忌影像)作為一個中立的術語,以反映並非所有違法的未成年人影像都是色情或虐待性質,且這些影像往往描繪的是年齡較大的未成年人,對他們而言,「兒童」一詞未必適用。我們並不否認存在色情、虐待性質且以極年幼兒童為主角的影像。然而,我們選擇採用精確的術語來處理此事,以涵蓋「被禁止的」範圍之全部內容,從對學步兒的駭人虐待,到由AI生成的、穿著比基尼擺姿勢的青少年卡通圖像等皆包含在內。若用「CSAM」(兒童性虐待材料)等術語用於指稱後者是非常荒謬的,此類充滿情緒色彩的語言,除了...
This article discusses a controversial pro-reform essay and concept titled The Push, introduced on Yesmap Wiki by BLueRibbon in May 2024.
Percy Shelley
Brian Ribbon

Foreword (Percy Shelley)
When Brian Ribbon returned to the MAP activist community in 2024 after a 14-year-long hiatus, his first piece entitled The Push generated a lot of controversy. It was intended as a warning that MAPs, facing all the various pressures arrayed against us, might act out of desperation in ways that hurt themselves and others. The essay was written from a place of frustration over trag...
Brian Ribbon

Earlier this month, I wrote an article focusing on the need for greater tolerance within our own community. I discussed various points of contention, such as alliances with other paraphiles, contact stances, and generational differences. The article generated a fair amount of criticism, which was inevitable. Let's consider some of the issues raised.
Identity politics within the community
One of the main criticisms in response to my article was my focus on identity politics, in particular the discussion of 'woke' ideology. Personally, I would not describe myself as 'woke...
Brian Ribbon
我在 MAP 議題上的許多寫作都是向外看的,關注世界對待我們有多麼殘酷。鑑於令人震驚的誤解、壓迫、謀殺以及其他種種惡劣現象的程度,這幾乎不足為奇。然而,有時向內看也很重要。在一篇發表於 Newgon Wiki 的 近期文章 中,我詢問了 MAP們為什麼我們的社群如此冷漠。在這篇相對簡短的文章中,我將討論我們需要「冷靜下來」的幾種方式。
性接觸立場

MAP社群中的一個主要分歧是「支持同意權派」(或稱支持性接觸派)與「反對性接觸派」。支持同意權派的成員通常主張成人-未成年人性接觸(簡稱AMSC)並非總是有害,並倡導法律變革。反對性接觸派的成員則主張成人-未成年人性接觸是有害且/或在道德上是錯誤的,並不倡導法律變革。
對許多支持同意權派的成員而言,反對性接觸派的主張者就像是叛徒,恨不得將他們投入監獄。與此同時,許多反對性接觸派的成員則視支持同意權派為毫不重視兒童福祉的恐龍。雙方都對純粹的理念有著強烈的執著,並對彼此懷有強烈的憤怒情緒。
也存在極端派系,例如 VirPed,該組織要求成員必須相信 AMSC 本質上永遠是錯誤的。除非完全認同其口號,否則該組織不會接納新成員。這種做法並無助益。然而,就大部分情況而言,性接觸意識形態上的分歧是被誇大了的。我最近提出了改革框架,呼籲謹慎的法律變革,其中包括16/12的混合年齡同意門檻。這得到了被視為巨大分歧兩端人士的支持,顯示出達成共識是可能的。
現實情況是,絕大多數支持同意權派...
Lead author: Brian Ribbon
Research, screenshots, formatting: Tommaso Battista, Jim Burton
This article was published in October 2024. At the time, the authors were not aware of Mr. Prosper's horrific plan to attack a school. As MAPs who are romantically attracted to young people in much the same way that 'normal' adults are attracted to other adults, we can't fathom how Mr. Prosper could possibly have chosen to target a school. In this instance, we are very thankful to the police for preventing such an awful atrocity.
Before reading this article, please view Mu's March 2025 statement.

Brian Ribbon
Percy Shelley
Pro-Reform is a framework arguing that cautious legal reforms are needed to offer greater rights and protections to MAPs and Youth. The framework being proposed is a personal position and not necessarily agreed upon by all members of Mu.
The pro-reform position is focused on maintaining a balance of freedoms, responsibilities and protections for MAPs and young people. Obviously, one of the most contentious issues is AMSC (Adult-Minor Sexual Contact). Almost always viewed through the negative lens of child sex abuse, legal definitions of what constitutes criminal sexual contact are highly arbitrary and vary significantly around the world....
Brian Ribbon
Pro-Reform is a framework arguing that cautious legal reforms are needed to offer greater rights and protections to MAPs and Youth. The framework is endorsed by myself as an individual, and the opinions expressed here are not necessarily agreed upon by all members of Mu.
Going forward, my editorials will feature discussions on MAPs, Youth, AMSC, PIM, and what I call 'The Push', where left-behind/ostracized MAPs might become a risk for criminality, violence or extremism. All of my writings will ultimately be underpinned by my pro-reform framework and consent philosophy.
Position statement on MAPs
The Pro-Reform position supports the destigmatiz...